Mr. Coffee vs Black and Decker
Are you looking for a high-quality, affordable coffee maker? Then you definitely want to check out Mr. Coffee vs Black and Decker. Both of these brands are well-respected in the industry.
They have been around for a long time because they are able to give you budget-friendly coffee makers that will make a delicious pot of coffee and last a long time. So, what features do they have, how are they different from each other, and which one is better? Let’s find out.
We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker:
The Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker is one of the most popular models on the market today. It is the perfect choice for beginners because of its simple and straightforward design.
You won’t have to worry about reading an instruction manual and figuring out all of the bells and whistles with this coffee machine. To use it all you have to do is turn the switch and it will do the rest. Once you put the water and coffee grounds it, the coffee maker will start to brew the coffee for you.
Don’t want to wait for it to be done brewing before you enjoy your first cup. No need. Just lift the glass carafe and the coffee maker will automatically pause the brewing process so you can pour a cup. Once you put it back down, the brewing process will resume. It doesn’t get any easier than that.
Pros:
- Simple design
- Easy to set up and use
- Dual water windows
- Brew-Pause Function
- Built-in cord storage
- Quick and simple to clean and maintain
- Affordable price point
Cons:
- Doesn’t have a programmable brew timer
- Doesn’t have an auto shut-off feature
- No permanent filter, have to use paper filters or buy a separate compatible reusable filter for it
Overall, this is a simple to use affordable coffee maker. Perfect for people who just want a quick and easy coffee maker, so they can enjoy their caffeinated beverage in the morning.
Black and Decker 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker:
The Black+Decker 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker is another high-quality, budget-friendly option for you. This one is not quite as simple to operate as the one above. However, it is still very easy to learn and use.
If you want a coffee maker that you can program ahead of time, then this is the one you should get. You can set it up before going to bed and wake up to a hot pot of coffee in the morning. This is great for those of us who want to sleep in as much as possible.
This coffee maker is a quick and efficient coffee machine. The hot plate will keep the coffee hot for an hour after you brew it. This coffee maker also features a 2-hour auto shut-off feature. You can just grab your coffee and be out the door.
Pros:
- Compact design
- Easy to use
- Transparent water reservoir window
- Programmable brew timer
- Brew-Pause feature
- Keep warm function
- 2-hour auto shut-off feature
- Quick and simple to clean and maintain
- Affordable price point
Cons:
- Only has one water window
- No permanent filter, you have to use paper filters or purchase a compatible, reusable filter for it
Overall, this is a simple and affordable coffee maker that gives you the features you want. It doesn’t add in the bells and whistles that you don’t need and raise the price. You can quickly get it set up, so you can wake up to a fresh pot of coffee in the morning.
Similarities of the Mr. Coffee & Black and Decker Coffee Makers:
Capacity:
There are many different sizes of coffee makers that you can own. Everything from single-serve coffee machines to larger coffee pots. Both the Mr. Coffee Machine and the Black+Decker Coffee Maker hold a maximum of 12 cups of coffee for you to enjoy.
These coffee machines are great for a family or small office who all share the coffee. These large coffee makers allow you to drink hot coffee for several hours.
Looking for a smaller coffee maker? Check out my article, Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers, to find the right one for you.
Carafe Type:
There are two carafe types that are popular when it comes to traditional, drip coffee makers. You can either have a glass carafe or a thermal stainless-steel carafe. Both the Mr. Coffee and the Black+Decker coffee machines use a glass carafe as their coffee pot.
This allows you to easily see how much coffee you have left. You will have a heads up when it is time to brew a new pot. Unfortunately, you have to be careful because glass carafes can easily break.
Filter Type:
There are two common filter types that coffee makers utilize. The first is a built-in permanent filter and the second is a one time use paper filter. Both of these coffee makers utilize paper filters. However, if you are worried about creating extra waste you do have the option to buy a separate reusable coffee filter that you can use in both of these coffee makers.
Removable Filter Basket:
Both of these coffee machines feature a removable filter basket. This makes it quick and simple to add coffee grounds without making a mess while doing it. You can also quickly clean it after you are done. Just take it out and rinse it off in the sink.
Water Reservoir:
The type of water reservoir that a coffee maker has is more important than you may think. This is especially true if you share the machine with others. We all know that it is common courtesy to refill the water reservoir for future pots of coffee if it is empty. However, sometimes it can be difficult to see just how much water remains inside.
This is why a water window is so important. It allows you to easily monitor the water level, so you know when it is close to being empty. Both of these coffee makers include a water reservoir window, so you can quickly and easily see how much water remains inside of the machine.
Brew-Pause Feature:
Can’t wait for that first cup of coffee in the morning? Then you definitely need to have a brew-pause feature on your coffee maker. Both of the Mr. Coffee and Black+Decker coffee machines include this feature so you can enjoy your first cup of hot coffee before the whole brewing process is complete. With this feature you can quickly pause the brewing process to pour a cup and then let it continue when you are done.
Warming Plate:
If you want your coffee to stay hot after it is done brewing, you will either need a thermal insulated carafe or a warming plate. Since both of these coffee makers use a glass carafe, which does not do a great job of keeping the coffee warm, they use a warming plate to help. The warming plate is underneath the glass carafe to keep the coffee hot, so that you can enjoy multiple cups of coffee throughout the morning.
Cord Storage:
Both the Mr. Coffee and Black+Decker machines feature built-in cord storage. This allows you to keep everything nice and tidy while you store the coffee makers away. We all hate having cords everywhere because they get tangled together and are a hassle to deal with. You won’t have to worry about any of this with these coffee makers.
Differences Between Mr. Coffee & Black and Decker:
Programmable Brew Timer:
If you are anything like me, then you definitely need a coffee maker with a programmable brew timer. I love being able to set everything up the night before, so I can wake up to a hot, fresh pot of coffee in the morning.
This allows you to enjoy your first cup while you are getting ready for work in the morning. You can then enjoy the rest throughout the morning and put it in a travel coffee mug to take with you on the go. You will no longer need to take the extra time to make your coffee in the morning. The Black+Decker Coffee Maker will automatically do it for you.
Water Reservoir Window(s):
As I stated above, both of the coffee machines feature a water reservoir window. The difference is that the Mr. Coffee machine has two windows, one on each side of the water reservoir. On the other hand, the Black and Decker Coffee Maker has only one. This may make it more difficult to monitor the water level depending on where you place the machine on your countertop.
Auto Shut-off Feature:
We have all experienced that morning when we are in a rush and running late. The last thing on our mind is remembering to turn off the coffee machine before we walk out the door. This is why the auto shut-off feature is so great. You can just pour your cup off coffee and move on with the rest of your day.
The Black and Decker includes this feature for you to utilize. You won’t have to worry about the warming plate burning the coffee or glass carafe because you forgot to turn the coffee maker off after you used it. If you are looking for a coffee machine that will make your life easier, then definitely consider buying this one.
Color Options:
There are difference color options that you can choose depending on which of these coffee machines you buy. The Mr. Coffee machine has two colors for you to choose. They are black and white. These machines are simple and neutral enough to fit in with any color scheme you may have in your kitchen.
The Black and Decker machine has a little more variety in the color options. The colors include black, white, and black with stainless steel. If you have stainless steel appliances in your kitchen then you may like the look of the Black and Decker coffee maker more.
As you can see, while there are many similarities there are also a few major differences for you to consider. One of these differences may be the deciding factor for you.
Final Thoughts: Which one should you choose?
Both the Mr. Coffee and the Black and Decker coffee makers will make a delicious pot of coffee for you to enjoy. You won’t be disappointed in either one of them. So, choosing which one is better will come down to your personal circumstance and needs.
If you just want a simple coffee machine that is easy to use, then you can’t do better than Mr. Coffee. However, if you want a few more bells and whistles to your coffee maker then you will want to choose the Black and Decker coffee maker. This will allow you to pre-program the brewing process to be ready in the morning and will automatically shut off for you.
If you are busy in the morning and don’t want to worry about making a pot of coffee before leaving for work, then you want to buy the Black and Decker. Hopefully, our comparison guide has helped you choose which one is better for you.
Related Articles:
Lattissima Touch vs Lattissima Plus: Which Should You Choose?
6 Best Coffee Makers for Hard Water
Benefits of Drinking Coffee Every Day